UK Environment Regulator Says Government Breaking Law Over Bird Decline
The UK’s independent environmental regulator has declared that the government is breaking the law by failing to intervene in the catastrophic decline of wild bird populations. New data reveals that bird numbers have fallen to their lowest level on record, with 45% of native breeding species in decline over the past five years.
The United Kingdom’s independent environmental regulator has declared that the government is in breach of the law by failing to take necessary action to halt the catastrophic decline of wild bird populations. The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) stated on Wednesday that Environment Secretary Angela Eagle, her department, and Natural England are all violating legal duties designed to protect nature.
The ruling follows the release of new data showing that wild bird numbers have dropped to their lowest level on record. According to the statistics, 45% of the 132 native breeding species monitored are in decline over a five-year period. The British Trust for Ornithology (BTO) estimates that Britain has lost more than 73 million wild birds from its landscape over the last five decades.
The species facing the steepest declines include some of the country’s most recognizable garden birds, such as swifts, turtledoves, tree sparrows, wood warblers, and bullfinches. These losses have prompted the OEP to conclude that ministers are failing in their legal responsibilities to recover bird populations to healthy levels and to designate Special Protection Areas (SPAs) where habitats are legally safeguarded.
Helen Venn, the chief regulatory officer for the OEP, emphasized that delays by ministers to protect bird populations have left a significant number of sites without the protection they require. "As a nation of bird lovers, and with birds acting as important indicators for the state of our nature more widely, the latest statistics showing declines in the populations of some of our most treasured species are deeply concerning," Venn said.
The regulator identified specific legal breaches by multiple government bodies. Environment Secretary Eagle is accused of breaching environmental law by failing to classify new SPAs, extend existing sites, or add species to those already under protection. Natural England is in breach for not taking the action needed to maintain or restore wild bird populations and ensure they have sufficient habitats.
Additionally, the government’s independent nature adviser has been accused of failing to carry out a required review of whether there is sufficient habitat for wild birds. The OEP noted that this review was intended to provide an expert assessment of habitat diversity and area, identify gaps, and explain the actions needed to support recovery.
Despite the ongoing ecological crisis, public interest in birdwatching continues to rise. The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) reported a 47% increase in the number of people enjoying birdwatching over the past eight years as of May. This growing engagement contrasts sharply with the lack of political progress on conservation.
Venn warned that continued delay has allowed the scale of action needed to deliver a sufficient SPA network to build up. There are currently 82 SPAs in England, along with six cross-border and offshore sites. The government is legally bound to expand these protected areas as part of its "30 by 30" commitment to protect at least 30% of land and seas for nature’s recovery by 2030.
Beccy Speight, chief executive of the RSPB, called for urgent action, including the designation of new and extended SPAs and targeted measures for species such as curlews, bitterns, and hen harriers. "Successive governments right across the UK have known about these problems for years," Speight said. "The time for navel-gazing has long passed; the time for taking action is now, before it is too late."
Defra’s latest statistics confirm that wild bird populations across the UK show no sign of widespread recovery, with both short- and long-term trends indicating that nearly half of all species are declining. The Department for Environment was approached for comment regarding the regulator's findings.
L.Amato--IM